Taking on new clients
Back to blog
Cold EmailLead Lists

The Worst Leads on My Lists Matched My ICP Perfectly

Cedric LausterNovember 19, 20266 min read

TL;DR: A lead can pass every filter you set, the right industry, the right size, the right title, and still never buy. The most common reason I see is simple: they already do in house what you are selling. I have had venture capital firms on a list for an outbound offer, a brand whose co-founder has 1.5 million followers on a list for an influencer agency, and a design-build firm with its own design team and cabinetry factory on a list for an interior designer. All three looked like a perfect fit on paper. Before a segment goes on a list, I now ask one question: would they pay for this, or do they already do it themselves?

Key Takeaways

  • Industry fit and buyer fit are different tests. A filter tells you a company looks like your client. It does not tell you whether they would ever pay you.
  • The most common way a perfect-looking lead fails is that they already have the capability in house.
  • Three signs give it away: a named role for the work, the service listed as part of their own offering, or their own production for it.
  • Some buying signals only fire for companies that already do the work. A firm that just opened a design showroom almost certainly has designers.
  • Run the test per segment before you build the list, and again per lead before anything personal goes out.

Why filters are not enough

Every list starts with filters: industry, headcount, location, job title. They are necessary. They are also the easy part, because every company that passes them looks like your client.

The question a filter cannot answer is whether this company would ever write you a check. That depends on things no database field holds: how they solve the problem today, who inside already owns it, and whether your service is something they buy or something they are.

I wrote about why industry filters shape the size of your list. This post is about the step after the filters, the one that decides whether the people on the list can buy at all.

Three leads that matched perfectly

Venture capital firms on a list for outbound. I was building a list of boutique financial firms for my own cold email offer. Venture capital and private equity looked right: financial services, small teams, owner-led. They fail the buyer test. Founders pitch venture capitalists all day, and private equity firms find deals through their own networks. Neither has a reason to pay for outbound pipeline. I had them on the include list before I asked who actually buys.

A creator-founded brand on a list for an influencer agency. For an influencer and UGC agency, I found a consumer brand that had just raised a seed round and landed national retail distribution. Fresh money, a launch, perfect timing. Then I looked at the founders. One of them is a creator with 1.5 million followers, and the brand grows through her audience. They already do influencer marketing, better than most agencies could. The lead I used instead was a brand run by a career sales operator with no personal following. Same moment, same funding stage, but with a real gap.

A design-build firm on a list for an interior designer. For an interior designer, I found a design-build firm in her area that had just opened a showroom. Right region, right timing. Their own site lists a general manager who is also a designer, says their design team will guide you, and mentions a 12,000 square foot cabinetry facility of their own. Interior design and custom cabinetry are two of her own service lines. That firm is not a client. It is a competitor.

How to spot it

Before a company goes on a list, look for three things:

  1. A named role for the work. A marketing manager, an in-house designer, a head of growth, a security lead. If someone's job title is your service, you are pitching against their job.
  2. The service in their own offering. Read their services page. If they sell what you sell, even as a side line, they are not buying it.
  3. Their own production. A studio, a factory, an in-house team, a large audience. Anything that means they produce the thing themselves.

None of these is hard to find. They sit on the company's own website, usually on the about, team or services page. The reason they get missed is that nobody looks once the filters say yes.

The signal trap

There is a sneakier version of this. Some buying signals only fire for companies that already have the capability.

The design showroom is the clearest example. "Firms that just opened a design showroom" sounds like a great signal for an interior designer: new space, fresh investment, a moment of change. But a firm that opens a design showroom almost by definition has design in house. The signal selects exactly the companies that will never buy.

What worked for her instead were residential developers that had just opened a sales gallery or model units. They need interior design for those spaces, and developers rarely employ their own designers.

Before you promise a signal in a cold email, check that the companies it finds can actually buy what you sell. A signal with no buyers in it is worse than no signal, because it looks like research.

Run the test twice

I run this test at two points.

Per segment, before the list is built. For every industry or sub-segment on the include list, ask: would a typical owner here pay for this, and what do they use today instead? If the answer is "their own team" or "something free that works", the segment comes off.

Per lead, before anything personal goes out. A segment can pass while a single company in it fails. When the email names one company or hands the reader one lead, read that company's own site first.

It takes a few minutes per segment. It saves you a campaign sent to people who were never going to buy, and the reply rate that makes you think your copy is the problem. Often the offer matters more than the copy, and the list decides who the offer even reaches.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between ICP fit and buyer fit?

ICP fit means a company matches your filters: industry, size, location, title. Buyer fit means that company would actually pay for your service. A company can match every filter and still never buy, most often because it already does the work in house.

How do I check whether a prospect already does my service in house?

Look at their own website. A job title that matches your service, the service listed on their own services page, or their own production for it, such as a studio, a team or a facility, all mean they are unlikely to buy it from you.

Should I remove a whole industry if some companies in it do the work in house?

Only if most of them do. If the typical company in the segment has the capability, take the segment off the list. If only some do, keep the segment and check each company before anything personal goes out.

Can a buying signal attract the wrong companies?

Yes. Some signals only fire for companies that already have the capability you sell, such as a firm opening a design showroom when you sell interior design. Check that the companies a signal finds could actually buy from you before you build a campaign around it.

Cedric Lauster

Cedric Lauster

Founder, Emmauris

LinkedIn →
Blog

Want this for your business?

Book a free strategy call. No pitch, no obligation.

Book a Free Call
Book a Call